Corrosion Resistance of Anodized Aluminum for Water-Cooled Electronic Assemblies
Power converters present unique challenges in electronic packaging and heat management. Their concentration of electrical energy, propensity for electro-magnetic interference generation, integration of heavy, irregularly shaped magnetic components, and requirements for compromised reliability and affordable cost oftentimes requires the use of liquid cooling. Historically, when liquid cooling is utilized copper has been the material of choice for the system's wetted elements. However, given its cost and weight advantages, latest generation systems have been turning to aluminum for wetted elements.
Thanks to the advancements in the electronics industry, high power electronic systems continue to become smaller and more space efficient. While air cooling remains the preferred cooling method for a wide range of application and power levels, liquid cooling has been gaining traction due to the demand for higher power from smaller packages. Typical liquid cooled systems utilize copper or aluminum cold plates as a heat transfer material due to their superior thermal conductivities and wide availability. While copper is considered to be the preferred material for high heat flux applications due to its higher thermal conductivity, aluminum offers significant cost savings and weight reductions for moderate heat flux applications.
Among the concerns in liquid cooling for electronics are potential cooling system leaks or cooling effectiveness degradation due to pitting and/or galvanic corrosion.
Pitting corrosion is the erosion of metal at small locations where a hole or a cavity is formed. Pitting erosion in water is affected by many factors; among the most significant are presence of chlorides and pH levels of the water.
Galvanic erosion occurs when two dissimilar metals are electrically connected in a conductive solution. The greater the separation in the anodic index for the two materials, the greater the galvanic corrosion potential and risk become, where the least noble metal starts corroding preferentially.
Anodic Index of Common Metals in Salt Water:
Astrodyne TDI's proprietary LiquaBlade utilizes aluminum alloy 6063-T5 cold plate heat exchangers protected with a sealed anodized finish for resistance to corrosion in a wide variety of applications.
These parts are critical to performance, especially in applications where corrosion inhibitors are not used, or there are copper components present in the same cooling system (such as wetted components in a chiller).
Either of these may promote galvanic corrosion. For this reason, an extensive study was conducted to evaluate pitting and galvanic corrosion resistances of 6063-T5 aluminum with various coatings in fresh water and de-ionized water applications.
The investigation s conducted in two phases. In Phase I, an experiment was conducted to visually examine the effects of un-plated or anodized aluminum plates (alloy 6063-T5) when commingled with un-plated copper in tap (fresh) water. For this, a closed circulation loop was designed, as pictured in Figure 2, and surface conditions of samples were monitored over 14 months.
In phase II, aluminum plates with three different coatings were sent to a NADCAP approved third party lab to perform pitting and galvanic corrosion testing to quantify corrosion rates both in tap and de-ionized water applications.
Phase I Testing:
Phase I testing was intended to provide qualitative evaluation of corrosion resistances of un-plated and anodized aluminum (per MIL-A-8625F8 Type II with Nickel Acetate Sealing) samples by running a long term testing, where samples were installed in closed loop circuits and surface conditions were visually examined periodically for signs of corrosion over the course of 18 months.
For this purpose, a closed loop cooling circuit was created. For each type of samples, two aluminum plates were mounted with an un-plated copper bar between them without being in contact. Water in the systems was replenished every 2 weeks.
Evidence of corrosion on the unprotected surfaces started to emerge within the first couple of days of testing and progressively worsened over time. At the end of week 16, the samples were taken out of the setup and visually inspected. The un-plated sample experience heavy pitting corrosion, where while aluminum oxide formation covered the entire plate. Testing on the un-plated aluminum samples was halted at this point.
The anodized aluminum sample after 16 weeks showed no signs of corrosion so it was kept in the circuit for prolonged testing. After 14 months of testing, the anodized sample was taken out of the setup for inspection and no signs of visible corrosion existed.
Phase II Testing:
Phase II testing was intended to provide more comprehensive analytical data on the corrosion resistance of various coatings on aluminum allot and 6063-T5 for both tap water and de-ionized water applications. Two separate sets of experiments (for pitting and galvanic erosion) were conducted at a NADCAP approved third party laboratory, to characterize the corrosion resistance of 6063-T5 aluminum allot having three different finishes namely, Type II anodize nickel plating and tin plating according to the following specifications:
- Anodized per MIL-A-8625F8 Type II with Nickel Acetate Sealing
- Tin plating per ASTM B545 Class B
- Nickel Plating per AMS-QQ-N-290B Class I Grade F
Corrosion potentials and current densities were measured and corrosion rates of samples were calculated
The first test was potentiodynamic testing samples in tap water and de-ionized water aimed at quantifying pitting corrosion resistance and corrosion rates. Samples were tested using ASTM G61-86(14) as a reference method. Tests were conducted in a local tap water and de-ionized water with 1ppm sodium phosphate solution added
Samples were mounted to support rods with conductive tape and the connection masked with a polymeric film. Test solutions were either local tap water (Lansing, New York) or distilled water with 1ppm sodium phosphate. Sodium phosphate was added to the DI water to improve the ionic conductivity, necessary for corrosion cell operation, without influencing the test results. (At levels of approximately 500ppm, sodium phosphate is often used as a corrosion inhibitor for aluminum alloys).
Tests were conducted using ASTM G61 as a guide. Test temperature was 50 degrees Celsius for all tests expect one test of nickel plated aluminum at 3 degrees Celsius. All solutions were continuously bubbled with compressed air at a rate of approximately 150cm3/min.
Corrosion rates were then calculated using the equations found in ASTM G 102 (Standard Practice for Calculation of Corrosion Rates and Related Information for Electrochemical Measurements). The density for the anodized aluminum was 3.95-g/cm3, for nickel 8.9-g/cm3, and for tin 7.3-g/cm3. The equivalent weights were 8.5, 29.36, and 59.34, respectively.
Test results show no samples exhibited corrosion; that is, all coatings withstood the test conditions without breaking down and allowing rapid local corrosion. All samples exhibited very low equilibrium corrosion rates far below 1mpy (mile per year). All samples exhibited faster corrosion in near-distilled water with 1 ppm sodium phosphate compared to tap water.
Anodized aluminum samples exhibited the lowest corrosion rates of approximately 2x10-4 mpy, while the tin plated samples had the highest corrosion rates of 0.05-0.09 mpy. Note, at a plating thickness of 0.1mil, minimum, the anodized aluminum heat exchanges used in LiquaBladeTM project a useful life of over 100 years before pitting corrosion would begin to degrade the underlying aluminum material.
Galvanic corrosion testing of aluminum samples with un-plated C11000 copper in tap water was also conducted. For this purpose, samples were lightly polished with 600 grit SiC prior to testing. Samples were then mounted on a steel rod using electrically conductive tape. (Note, the presence of the steel rod connecting the samples provides an enhanced pat for galvanic corrosion to occur and thus represents a highly conservative test method).
Testing was performed using the guidance of ASTM G71 (Standard Guide for Conducting and Evaluating Galvanic Corrosion Tests in Electrolytes). The potential was monitored using a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) as the reference electrode. For this test, the aluminum sample acts as the anode and the copper sample acts as the cathode. Testing was conducted for 168 hours at 50oC using local tap water aerated at rate of approximately 150-cm3/min. Exposed area for each sample was approximately 4 cm2 with a cathode to anode area ratio of 1 +/- 0.05.
Test results showing the corrosion potentials and current densities as a function of time are shown in the following figures, for anodized, nickel plated and tin plated samples, respectively. The data from the final day of exposure were used to calculate the long term average current density and the corrosion rates using the same equations found in ASTM G102 Standard.
The results indicate anodized aluminum exhibited the best corrosion resistance with >0.01 mpy corrosion rate, while tin plated aluminum had 0.17 mpy and nickel plated aluminum had the highest corrosion rate at 3.0 mpy.
Note at a plating thickness of 0.1mil, minimum, the anodized aluminum heat exchanges used in LiquaBladeTM, taking into account the highly conservative nature of this test, project a useful life of well over 10 years before galvanic corrosion would begin to degrade the underlying aluminum material.
A two phase investigation on corrosion resistance of aluminum allot 6063-T5 in water cooled packaging applications was carried out. The first phase of the investigation, a qualitative evaluation of corrosion development on un-plated and anodized aluminum samples was performed. Results revealed that corrosion develops rapidly on un-plated aluminum surfaces and oxide later forms within days. After only 16 weeks of testing, the sample exhibited signs of severe pitting corrosion. In contrast, an anodized aluminum sample showed no signs of corrosion sites even after 14 months of continuous testing.
To further the investigation, a more comprehensive analysis was conducted to evaluate the corrosion resistance of anodized, nickel plated and tin plated aluminum in tap and de-ionized water, as well as with copper in the system as the dissimilar material. With this study, both pitting and galvanic corrosion rates were quantified.
None of the samples showed any signs of pitting corrosion, where anodized aluminum exhibited the lowest corrosion rates among all in every condition (corrosion rates being smaller than 2.10-4 mils per year for pitting corrosion and 0.01 mils per year for galvanic corrosion with the presence of copper).
The anodized aluminum heat exchangers used in Astrodyne TDI's LiquaBladeTM product project well over 10 years useful life when utilized in cooling systems that also feature copper wetted components.