RESOURCES

Modular Power versus Customized Designs: Choosing the Perfect Power Supply


Power generation is complex and technical, and choosing the correct power supply is essential for any application. Many industries have unique power supply requirements, requiring a specific approach like modular and customized designs. Understanding which is best suited to your application is essential.

What Is a Modular Power Supply?

A modular or configurable power supply consists of premade power supply units (PSUs) that can be combined and configured by the vendor or in the field to suit your specific needs. In many cases, PSUs require different DC outputs to power various system elements. Modular supplies can interact with multiple output modules to provide adjustable output voltages. With modular power supplies, you can configure a quick solution. 

One of the main characteristics of a modular power supply is detachable cabling, providing the flexibility of multiple outputs. They often consist of a mains-connected front end and a suitable number of DC output modules. The front end housethe electromagnetic compatibility filtering, fuses, surge protection, isolation transformer, and power factor correction. Power is transferred from the front end to each of the DC modules. These modules process that power and provide a regulated DC output.

When to Use Modular Power Supplies

Configurable power supplies suit numerous applications, mainly when time-to-market and flexibility are top priorities. Modular power supplies are an excellent choice for uses in projects with frequent specification changes – where otherwise fixed, “closed-box” PSUs prevent engineers from working around pre-determined power specifications that are found to be falling short. Many industries can benefit from modular power, including healthcare and telecommunications.

There is a vast constellation of use cases, some everyday use cases include:

  • Measurement and testing systems
  • Industrial machinery
  • Laser and electrical equipment
  • Mechanical applications

What Is a Custom Power Supply?

Custom power supplies are created specifically for your application. Experts design them to fulfill non-standard input or output voltage requirements or complex enclosure shapes. Custom design can be a detailed modification of a standard power module or a completely new product built from the component level. They can consist of any component based on your unique specifications.

When to Use Custom Power Supplies

Custom power supplies are ideal for any application where a standard option is unsuited. They can provide a reliable option in challenging environments as they're purpose-built to meet your specific performance requirements. These features make them ideally positioned to meet military, scientific, and industrial needs.

You can customize your power supply to include wide operating temperature ranges, unusual form factors, and single or multiple outputs. Some everyday use cases include:

  • Battery production, conditioning, and charging
  • LED lighting
  • Medical and university laboratories
  • Laboratories
  • Low-power AC to DC conversion requirements
  • Production line equipment 
  • Instrumentation

Modular vs. Custom Power Supplies: Key Differences

The principal difference between modular and custom power supplies is that modular options are configurable to a point, and custom supplies are purpose-built to meet specific requirements. Each option has pros and cons, and knowing the advantages and limitations is essential to properly selecting one over the other.

The Benefits of a Modular Power Supply

Modular power units have significant benefits, some of which include:

  • Increase airflow and cooling: One of the principal advantages of modular supply is that you can limit cable use to what you need, leading to better cable management and cooling. Maintaining a consistent temperature leads to better performance in your overall system.
  • Clean and maintain easily: When you need to clean a modular supply, it's as simple as disconnecting the PSU side, making these power supplies easy to maintain.
  • Increase your options: Modular power allows a single platform to serve a variety of options via the population and depopulation of individual modules.
  • Maintain compliance: Power conversion choices can affect compliance with industry regulations. A configurable option means your system will maintain compliance, as the modules are manufactured to meet industry requirements.
  • Work within a budget: Configurable power supplies are easily scalable, allowing you the flexibility to work within a specific budget without losing performance.

The Drawbacks of a Modular Power Supply

Some drawbacks of these power supplies include:

  • Failed connectors: Modular PSUs are subject to wear and tear when the connectors are repeatedly connected and disconnected. Over time, repeated use can lead to frequent replacements.
  • Space requirements: Configurable power supplies can be complex. The modules, cables, and ports can be bulky, increasing space requirements and costs.
  • Limited flexibility: While modular PSUs are more flexible than non-modular options, they have limitations in specific environments and may only meet some of your needs.

The Benefits of a Custom Power Supply

Custom power supplies offer numerous advantages, including:

  • Meet unique performance requirements: Custom power supplies are built to meet all your needs and maximize system performance.
  • Improve longevity: Reliability over time is critical for many power systems. The specific design and manufacture of custom PSUs result in stringent component derating, which can increase the lifetime of your system.
  • Increase reliability: Custom power supplies can be built to withstand the most demanding operational environments while maintaining maximum efficiency and power output. 
  • Customize packaging: PSU weight and size are crucial considerations in some applications. Custom power supplies can meet your size constraints and packaging requirements, including fans for self-cooling, conductively cooled base plates, and any other essential modifications. 
  • Reduce system components and costs: Modular options may include additional features not required for your application. Custom options remove these components, which can result in cost savings. 

The Drawbacks of a Custom Power Supply

A few potential downsides of custom power supplies are:

  • Higher upfront cost: Designing and manufacturing a custom power supply is often more costly than using a modular option. 
  • Time constraints: It takes longer to create custom PSUs, and the manufacturer must source each component and build the unit while you wait. Custom power supplies require planning, making them unsuitable for urgent requirements. 
  • Increased risk: If something happens to your custom unit, the solution is more complex than buying another one. Working with a reliable manufacturer is essential to avoid the risks associated with a vendor that doesn't offer long-term support. 

How to Choose the Right Power Supply for Your Application

Selecting a suitable power supply option is essential for any application. Consider the following points:

  1. Safety and protection: Any power supply you choose should be safe for the intended environment. While modular options are excellent for simplifying compliance, they may pose risks in challenging environments. Customs options are better suited to unique applications.
  2. Energy efficiency: Maximizing usable energy is essential, and your PSU should have adequate cooling and be as energy efficient as possible to cut costs and boost your overall sustainability. Consider whether all the components in a potential system are necessary for your application.
  3. Size: High-power applications often require large PSUs. Consider how much space you can use to house your PSUs and discuss your options with the manufacturer.
  4. Budget: Your power supply should enhance operations and provide the best return on investment. Discuss your budget with your manufacturer so you can develop a practical solution.
  5. Manufacturer: Uninterruptible power is non-negotiable in many industries. Choose a reputable vendor that offers after-sale support to ensure minimal downtime for maintenance and repairs.

Reach Out to Astrodyne TDI for All Your Power Supply Needs

Choosing the ideal power supply for your application can be challenging, but Astrodyne TDI can simplify your choice. We specialize in providing reliable power supplies in many industries, including industrial, medical, military, and aerospace. We can provide custom and configurable power supply options, solving power supply challenges in competitive manufacturing times.

At Astrodyne TDI, we can bring the technical support and industry expertise you need to select the correct power supply for your needs, including developing and configuring unique solutions. Let us worry about the power so you don't have to. Feel free to request a quote or find a sales rep today for more information.

 

Modular Power vs. Customized Designs

Power generation is complex and technical, and choosing the correct power supply is essential for any application. Many industries have unique power supply requirements, requiring a specific approach like modular and customized designs. Understanding which is best suited to your application is essential.

What Is a Modular Power Supply?

A modular or configurable power supply consists of premade power supply units (PSUs) that can be combined and configured by the vendor or in the field to suit your specific needs. In many cases, PSUs require different DC outputs to power various system elements. Modular supplies can interact with multiple output modules to provide adjustable output voltages. With modular power supplies, you can configure a quick solution. 

One of the main characteristics of a modular power supply is detachable cabling, providing the flexibility of multiple outputs. They often consist of a mains-connected front end and a suitable number of DC output modules. The front end housethe electromagnetic compatibility filtering, fuses, surge protection, isolation transformer, and power factor correction. Power is transferred from the front end to each of the DC modules. These modules process that power and provide a regulated DC output.

When to Use Modular Power Supplies

Configurable power supplies suit numerous applications, mainly when time-to-market and flexibility are top priorities. Modular power supplies are an excellent choice for uses in projects with frequent specification changes – where otherwise fixed, “closed-box” PSUs prevent engineers from working around pre-determined power specifications that are found to be falling short. Many industries can benefit from modular power, including healthcare and telecommunications.

There is a vast constellation of use cases, some everyday use cases include:

  • Measurement and testing systems
  • Industrial machinery
  • Laser and electrical equipment
  • Mechanical applications

What Is a Custom Power Supply?

Custom power supplies are created specifically for your application. Experts design them to fulfill non-standard input or output voltage requirements or complex enclosure shapes. Custom design can be a detailed modification of a standard power module or a completely new product built from the component level. They can consist of any component based on your unique specifications.

When to Use Custom Power Supplies

Custom power supplies are ideal for any application where a standard option is unsuited. They can provide a reliable option in challenging environments as they're purpose-built to meet your specific performance requirements. These features make them ideally positioned to meet military, scientific, and industrial needs.

You can customize your power supply to include wide operating temperature ranges, unusual form factors, and single or multiple outputs. Some everyday use cases include:

  • Battery production, conditioning, and charging
  • LED lighting
  • Medical and university laboratories
  • Laboratories
  • Low-power AC to DC conversion requirements
  • Production line equipment 
  • Instrumentation

Modular vs. Custom Power Supplies: Key Differences

The principal difference between modular and custom power supplies is that modular options are configurable to a point, and custom supplies are purpose-built to meet specific requirements. Each option has pros and cons, and knowing the advantages and limitations is essential to properly selecting one over the other.

The Benefits of a Modular Power Supply

Modular power units have significant benefits, some of which include:

  • Increase airflow and cooling: One of the principal advantages of modular supply is that you can limit cable use to what you need, leading to better cable management and cooling. Maintaining a consistent temperature leads to better performance in your overall system.
  • Clean and maintain easily: When you need to clean a modular supply, it's as simple as disconnecting the PSU side, making these power supplies easy to maintain.
  • Increase your options: Modular power allows a single platform to serve a variety of options via the population and depopulation of individual modules.
  • Maintain compliance: Power conversion choices can affect compliance with industry regulations. A configurable option means your system will maintain compliance, as the modules are manufactured to meet industry requirements.
  • Work within a budget: Configurable power supplies are easily scalable, allowing you the flexibility to work within a specific budget without losing performance.

The Drawbacks of a Modular Power Supply

Some drawbacks of these power supplies include:

  • Failed connectors: Modular PSUs are subject to wear and tear when the connectors are repeatedly connected and disconnected. Over time, repeated use can lead to frequent replacements.
  • Space requirements: Configurable power supplies can be complex. The modules, cables, and ports can be bulky, increasing space requirements and costs.
  • Limited flexibility: While modular PSUs are more flexible than non-modular options, they have limitations in specific environments and may only meet some of your needs.

The Benefits of a Custom Power Supply

Custom power supplies offer numerous advantages, including:

  • Meet unique performance requirements: Custom power supplies are built to meet all your needs and maximize system performance.
  • Improve longevity: Reliability over time is critical for many power systems. The specific design and manufacture of custom PSUs result in stringent component derating, which can increase the lifetime of your system.
  • Increase reliability: Custom power supplies can be built to withstand the most demanding operational environments while maintaining maximum efficiency and power output. 
  • Customize packaging: PSU weight and size are crucial considerations in some applications. Custom power supplies can meet your size constraints and packaging requirements, including fans for self-cooling, conductively cooled base plates, and any other essential modifications. 
  • Reduce system components and costs: Modular options may include additional features not required for your application. Custom options remove these components, which can result in cost savings. 

The Drawbacks of a Custom Power Supply

A few potential downsides of custom power supplies are:

  • Higher upfront cost: Designing and manufacturing a custom power supply is often more costly than using a modular option. 
  • Time constraints: It takes longer to create custom PSUs, and the manufacturer must source each component and build the unit while you wait. Custom power supplies require planning, making them unsuitable for urgent requirements. 
  • Increased risk: If something happens to your custom unit, the solution is more complex than buying another one. Working with a reliable manufacturer is essential to avoid the risks associated with a vendor that doesn't offer long-term support. 

How to Choose the Right Power Supply for Your Application

Selecting a suitable power supply option is essential for any application. Consider the following points:

  1. Safety and protection: Any power supply you choose should be safe for the intended environment. While modular options are excellent for simplifying compliance, they may pose risks in challenging environments. Customs options are better suited to unique applications.
  2. Energy efficiency: Maximizing usable energy is essential, and your PSU should have adequate cooling and be as energy efficient as possible to cut costs and boost your overall sustainability. Consider whether all the components in a potential system are necessary for your application.
  3. Size: High-power applications often require large PSUs. Consider how much space you can use to house your PSUs and discuss your options with the manufacturer.
  4. Budget: Your power supply should enhance operations and provide the best return on investment. Discuss your budget with your manufacturer so you can develop a practical solution.
  5. Manufacturer: Uninterruptible power is non-negotiable in many industries. Choose a reputable vendor that offers after-sale support to ensure minimal downtime for maintenance and repairs.

Reach Out to Astrodyne TDI for All Your Power Supply Needs

Choosing the ideal power supply for your application can be challenging, but Astrodyne TDI can simplify your choice. We specialize in providing reliable power supplies in many industries, including industrial, medical, military, and aerospace. We can provide custom and configurable power supply options, solving power supply challenges in competitive manufacturing times.

At Astrodyne TDI, we can bring the technical support and industry expertise you need to select the correct power supply for your needs, including developing and configuring unique solutions. Let us worry about the power so you don't have to. Feel free to request a quote or find a sales rep today for more information.